Review of Upcoming Release True by Erin McCarthy

Book Cover

Pre-order from Amazon: True

Release Date: May 7, 2013

True by Erin McCarthy

Book Description (from Amazon)

A New Adult novel from USA Today bestselling author Erin McCarthy

When Rory Macintosh’s roommates find out that their studious and shy friend has never been with a guy, they decide that, as an act of kindness they’ll help her lose her virginity by hiring confident, tattooed bad boy Tyler Mann to do the job…unbeknownst to Rory.

Tyler knows he’s not good enough for Rory. She’s smart, doctor smart, while he’s barely scraping by at his EMT program, hoping to pull his younger brothers out of the hell their druggy mother has left them in. But he can’t resist taking up her roommates on an opportunity to get to know her better. There’s something about her honesty that keeps him coming back when he knows he shouldn’t…

Torn between common sense and desire, the two find themselves caught up in a passionate relationship. But when Tyler’s broken family threatens to destroy his future, and hers, Rory will need to decide whether to cut her ties to his risky world or follow her heart, no matter what the cost… 

Book Review

I just finished the most wonderful story

This is my first time reading Erin McCarthy’s work and wow! I am impressed. I read this book in one day, and that’s unusual for me. Rory Macintosh’s witty point-of-view is what kept my initial interest; then the unlikely relationship that emerges between Rory and Tyler Mann just took me on an emotional rollercoaster ride that was so worth it!

College years are tough, and apparently, today, being a virgin doesn’t help your social status one bit.  The story introduces readers to twenty-year-old Rory, whose virginal status becomes public knowledge at a Friday night party.  Rory isn’t a social butterfly compared to her roommates, Jessica and Kylie, and she’s never had a boyfriend. Rory’s always been focused on her academic studies and obtaining a medical degree, but it isn’t as if she doesn’t want to date or even have a make out session with a guy; she just hasn’t met anyone whose interested. However, when a drunken guy tries to sexually assault her at this party, Rory is rescued by the local tattooed, pierced Tyler, who intervenes.  Still in shock from the incident, Rory inadvertently confesses to her roommates and everyone around that she is still a virgin.

Having had too much to drink and being in a dangerous neighborhood gives Rory an incentive to accept Tyler’s offer to drive her home. She is initially intimidated by him, but as they talk during the drive, she begins to realize that he’s not so different from her after all.  Because they each come from families where the physical expression of love and affection was rarely shown, they both keep others at a distance. She starts to relax around him until he begins to question her about her virginity.

 photo gif-life-quote-text-typography-Favimcom-373188excusemeforbeingavirgin_zpsef09f96b.gif

Her defensive response elicits a laugh for him making her feel that he doesn’t see her as a “freak.” Rory often feels out of place because of her social awkwardness and her inability to always understand the dynamics of human behavior.

She reminds me of Sheldon from The Big Bang Theory who is well-known for his dispassionate, scientific-like observation of others.

 photo tumblr_inline_mi2999mkuK1qz4rgpmakingfriends_zpse70b40ed.gif

The story is told from Rory’s-point-of-view, and her insightful observations, witticism, and sarcasm bring realness to her character on a level that resonated with me. She is WYSIWYG: (what you see is what you get). There is nothing superficial about her. She’s logical and methodical, and at times too literal in her thinking, and she doesn’t always feel inhibited about sharing these thoughts either.

 photo tumblr_mbx25zhYDh1qkk6oystupidistthingeverheard_zps95af7487.gif

However, Rory is never mean-spirited; she tries hard to see the good in people, which makes her such a likeable character. McCarthy’s writing is refreshing and entertaining in her portrayal of Rory and in the playful bantering with Tyler as they become friends.

At first Rory is suspicious of Tyler. Instead of just dropping her off at her dorm after the night of the party, he stops by to check when she has a massive hangover; he drops by to see her at work, and he suggests they study together, and just hang out.

She could never imagine that Tyler, would be interested in her, yet his flirting and sexual innuendo suggest otherwise. When he finally lets her know he wants to move beyond flirting, she finally gives in being swayed by his memorable kisses.  She even expects that making out with him will lead to sex, but instead he takes her home. His behavior doesn’t fit with his reputation as a one to have casual sex with no strings, and she feels a sense of rejection that he didn’t try harder to get her into bed.

Thinking that Tyler and Rory have slept together, Jessica and Kylie drunkenly discuss the deal the financial deal they made with Tyler to have him “de-virginize” her. When Rory overhears their conversation, she is devastated by the news. Her pain is so heart-wrenching, I ached for her.

 photo shock_zps6f783eaf.gif

She lets her friends think Tyler fulfilled his end of the bargain and doesn’t expect to hear from him again. Surprisingly, Tyler continues to text her and makes efforts to see her, expressing his disappointment when she avoids him. She has a hard time reconciling this warm-hearted, seemingly genuine guy with the one willingly took money to seduce her.

When Tyler takes her to his house unexpectedly, thinking there is an emergency, Rory begins to have a deeper understanding of Tyler’s true character. He lives in squalor with his younger brothers and alcoholic, drug addicted mother. He carries the burden of taking care of his brothers while working and going to school to get a degree as an EMT. This isn’t his ideal career choice, but he knows it will enable him to secure a decent job and be able to take his brothers away from their dysfunctional living situation.

Rory admires Tyler’s protective nature of his brothers and his perseverance to overcome such overwhelming obstacles. Seeing Tyler in this vulnerable state, feeling ashamed and embarrassed, is a primary factor in solidifying their relationship into one of more than just friendship.

 photo sweetestguyiveeverknown_zpsfc4a4ad1.gif

Like Rory, I just wanted to wrap my arms around Tyler and his brothers and hug them for what they have to endure.

As they continue to spend time together, Rory realizes she’s fallen in love with Tyler and she’s ready to take the next step in becoming intimate with him. When she blurts out that she loves him, Tyler decides to bolt.

As they continue to spend time together, Rory realizes she’s fallen in love with Tyler and she’s ready to take the next step in becoming intimate with him. When she blurts out that she loves him, Tyler decides to bolt. Yet, Rory bravely tracks him down and just lays it all on the line, her hurt, frustration, insecurities, and her desire for him. Her boldness compels Tyler to be just as forthcoming, and he reveals his true motivation for the bargain he made with her roommates, as well as the love he feels for her, even though he doesn’t feel worthy of her love. Their raw honesty with each other is so refreshing to me.

As we all know, when the conflict ends, the story ends, and it isn’t time for that to happen. While Rory is home for Christmas break, she receives shocking news that Tyler has gotten himself into serious trouble, with serious consequences that will change his life and the future of their relationship.

 photo tumblr_m38k4rcJr61qmhpuoyellingsomethinginangershock_zpsbe05ac06.gif

This is a powerful, believable story that sucked me in from the beginning and didn’t let go until the very end. I have to admit, I wasn’t satisfied with ending. I wanted an epilogue; I wanted something more.  Actually, there’s nothing  wrong with the ending. In fact, it’s appropriate considering that this looks to be the start of a series with Jessica’s story the focus of the next book. I’m sure the continuing thread of their relationship will be incorporated into her story. I just wasn’t ready for the experience to be over.

I received an ARC of this book from Penguin Group/Signet Romance via NetGalley for an honest review.


top of the mountain copy40

About Erin McCarthy

USA Today and New York Times Bestselling author Erin McCarthy sold her first book in 2002 and has since written almost fifty novels and novellas in teen fiction, new adult, and adult romance. Erin has a special weakness for New Orleans, tattoos, high-heeled boots, beaches and martinis. She lives in Ohio with her family, two grumpy cats and a socially awkward dog. (from Goodreads)

Author Links

Erin McCarthy Website


Goodreads Profile


music blue black round 50

Music to Complement the Book

Sound Garden “Truly, Madly, Deeply”

To post a comment, please click on the green link “Leave a Comment” located after the tags at the bottom of this post.